Marion
The bottle contains 120 ml of liquid and since it removes the make-up relatively fast with a small amount of product it lasts for about 3 weeks. However, it tends to irritate my eyes a little bit so I would give it the third place. The list of ingredients includes camomile extract but it's at the very end.
Ziaja
There is 120 ml of product in the bottle. It removes the make-up as fast as Marion but a little bit more product is needed so a container lasts for about 2 weeks. It doesn't irritate my eyes at all and the residue it leaves is the least greasy. With Marion and Bielenda you can't see very well a minute after using them which drives me mad but you don't have this problem with Ziaja. I also really like the fact that the list of ingredients is so short because there is less possibility that something can cause allergic reaction. It also claims to have the same pH as the tears. It is my favourite.
Bielenda
There are three versions of the product available - avocado (yellow cap - for sensitive eyes), black olive (black cap - anti-aging) and cotton (pink cap - strengthening the eyelashes). I currently have two of them but I've tried them all and they are comparable. The bottle contains 125 ml of product but it dissolves the make-up rather slowly so it doesn't last longer than Ziaja. I haven't noticed any difference as far as my lashes are concerned, I don't believe in the anti-aging properties either. I can't say if the avocado version is more gentle than the rest because my eyes are not sensitive. For me they work exactly the same. Bielenda leaves the most greasy residue on the eyes and doesn't sink into the cotton pad very well - it tends to slip and get on the floor. The list of ingridients is rather long but includes hialuronic acid, allantonin, arginine but also parabens .However, it doesn't irritate my eyes so I would give it the second place.
And what are your favourite eye make-up removers?
Have a nice day,
Snow White
